Skip to main content

Main menu

  • Playground
  • Surfacing
  • Parks
  • Athletics
  • Aquatics
  • Play
Home
  • Playground
  • Surfacing
  • Parks
  • Athletics
  • Aquatics
  • Play
  • Build a Sandbox
  • The Play Value Of Sand
  • With Community Helpers the Play Lady Receives the Fred Rodgers Helpers Award
  • Texas Legislating Recess
  • Keeping the Fun in Fundraising
  • See Accessibility Through the Eyes of a Child
  • Outdoor Play for Children with Intellectual Disabilities on Playgrounds

Breadcrumb

  1. Home
  2. Playground
  3. Inclusion
  4. Play and social justice: Who gets to play?

Play and social justice: Who gets to play?

Inclusion
December 17, 2013
Profile picture for user John Sutterby
By John Sutterby on
  • facebook-f
  • twitter
  • envelope
  • print
821
Play and social justice: Who gets to play?

Play and social justice: Who gets to play?

Play and social justice: Who gets to play?
Play and social justice: Who gets to play?

A couple of weeks back I attended the annual conference of the National Association for the Education of Young Children (NAEYC) in our nation’s capital, Washington, DC. The conference is one of the largest in the field of education and focuses on the educational needs of children birth to age eight.

The conference itself is just an amazing affair. Picture mostly women wearing comfortable shoes (because no one teaches prekindergarten in high heels), brightly colored t-shirts that say things like “I’m retired, I was tired yesterday and I’m retired today” and “teachers do it with class.” They also like funny hats, learning the newest kid music, and getting free samples of soy butter snacks. Basically, they are some really great people who are taking care of our most precious resource, our children.

This conference is also a great one to talk about play. My own presentation was on play and social justice along with my colleagues Olga Jarrett and Vera Stenhouse from Georgia State University and Darlene DeMarie from the University of South Florida. Play and social justice was clearly a topic of interest as we had more than 50 people in attendance.

Our social justice focus was on where children get to play and which children get to play in schools and playgrounds. A few of the topics we presented were on what type of play space is available to children, what policies are in place that impact who gets to play and the sometimes differential impact that occurs when teachers and administrators determine who gets to play on a child by child basis.

We as a group of presenters who have been working on this topic for many years feel that all children should have relatively similar opportunities to play regardless of their economic status, and they should not be denied opportunities to play because of race, gender, or ability. Under the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child is the Article 31 (Leisure, play and culture). This states that “children have the right to relax and play, and to join in a wide range of cultural, artistic and other recreational activities.” We feel that when children are denied opportunities to play, then their rights as children are being violated.

Although we discussed many topics as part of our presentation, I wanted to share two topics that we shared across geographical contexts.

The first was access to quality play environments at public schools. I would hope that all children no matter their race or economic status or ability would have access to quality play environments, but the reality is that is not the case. The difference between what is available at wealthier public schools is often very different from what is available at lower income schools. A case in point, this first photograph is from a school in Texas. The children in this school are mostly low income, mostly African American.

Top Photo above from The Houston Chronicle

On the other hand, the school playgrounds (shown below) available to a wealthy school district with mostly wealthy children look very different. There are two large playgrounds and more than a dozen swings.

 

Play and social justice: Who gets to play?

Play and social justice: Who gets to play?

There is a confluence of reasons why these playgrounds look so different. Districts which stretch every penny often have to make decisions that do not allow for large expenditures on playground equipment. Parent Teacher Organizations also can have an impact by raising money for playground equipment. Whatever the reason, we should all expect that all children deserve to have access to a place to play that is safe and challenging. The question that occurs to me is, which playground would you prefer for your child?

The second topic we discussed at the conference is who gets to play. What we have been finding across many contexts is that school policies are limiting recess and access to physical activity. These school policies are disproportionately affecting children from low income backgrounds and more frequently children who are Hispanic or African American. A big culprit is on an increasing emphasis on standardized testing in schools. School districts and school administrators in low income districts are more likely to decrease recess than school districts that are more affluent. Children who are at risk of failure on school tests are more likely to be kept from recess.

Now I want all children to succeed, but I also feel all children need to have the opportunity to play and have recess. I could even argue that having recess is more likely to lead to success on standardized tests, but from a social justice standpoint, just the fact that some children get recess because they are from wealthier backgrounds is just not right and something we should not stand for if we think fairness is important.

Not all was negative, many parent groups and professional organizations have spoken up about making sure children get recess. Other groups like SPARK School Park Program and KaBOOM! are working to make playgrounds more available to more children.

Isn’t that just right?

Profile picture for user John Sutterby
John Sutterby
Published 9 years ago
Last updated 10 months ago
821
3
min read
A- A+
  • facebook-f
  • twitter
  • envelope
  • print

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter

More About

Multi-function equipment
Oct 18, 2017
Inclusion

How Diverse Play Equipment Leads to an Inclusive Playground

Emily Matlovich
Inclusion
Aug 20, 2019
Inclusion

A Place for Everyone

Michele Breakfield
Ways To Help Children With Down Syndrome Thrive
Mar 10, 2021
Inclusion

Ways To Help Children With Down Syndrome Thrive

PGP
How Can Playing Outdoors Help Children with Autism?
Apr 07, 2020
Inclusion

How Can Playing Outdoors Help Children with Autism?

Jackie Edwards
Jun 22, 2015
Inclusion

Reference of Inclusion Organizations

Playground Magazine
Jun 21, 2019
Inclusion

Inclusive Play in 2019

Mara Kaplan
Equitable upper body climbing activities are illustrated in these side by side play elements. Close proximity is key.
Feb 06, 2017
Inclusion

Building Inclusive Play Spaces By Considering The Whole Child, Whole Environment, And Whole Community

Anne-Marie-Spencer
IPEMA Takes Proactive Stance On New ADA Standards
Apr 01, 2012
Inclusion

IPEMA Takes Proactive Stance On New ADA Standards

Playground Magazine
Melody Day Receives Youth  Champion 4 Inclusion Award
Sep 22, 2020
Inclusion

Melody Day Receives Youth Champion 4 Inclusion Award

Victoria Babb
Different types of equipment help accessibility.
Nov 08, 2017
Inclusion

How to Create a Playground For All Abilities

Sally Keys
Reeve Brenner - Bankshot Sports
Mar 30, 2015
Inclusion

The ADA Milestone Reconsidered

Reeve Brenner
Apr 15, 2013
Inclusion

"One Size Fits All" Does Not Work

Kenneth Kutska

Inclusion Professionals

Skulski Consulting LLC
Skulski Consulting LLC
Services
More
AMPED2PLAY
AMPED2PLAY
Organization
More
Learning Landscapes Design LLC
Learning Landscapes Design LLC
Services
More
Home

Follow Us

Play and playground news and information since 2001

  • instagram
  • facebook-f
  • twitter
  • pinterest
  • linkedin

Company

  • Playground Magazine
  • Contributors
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe

Copyright © 2001 - 2023 Playground Professionals, LLC

Footer menu

  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms and conditions